First, agree on what the words mean
Here, capitalism and socialism are told apart by who owns the land and tools used to make things. Do individuals or companies own them, or does society as a whole manage them democratically? That looks like the big dividing line.
There are also ideas of socialism that use markets. There's also a view that even if a state manages the economy, it isn't called socialism if working people can't take part in deciding things. You can't sort it as “there's buying and selling, so it's capitalism” or “there's a manager, so it's socialism.”
Telling apart why things move
Pay that a qualification is said to raise, a sweet for a celebration, a house won in a sweepstakes. The reasons for receiving each are different. Even in the same world, there's more than one way for things to change hands.
Still, you can't say that because there are gifts, things are owned in common, or that because a house was won, everyone's housing is guaranteed. I want to check what is guaranteed, and for whom.
Things to check before deciding on a name
Can workers talk things over and set the terms? Who do the tools and places belong to? There are still things I want to know in order to compare.
Using words from real-world society makes it easier to explain what catches my attention in the story. They're not for guessing what the author thinks, but a tool for reading scenes side by side.
Sources
- スタンフォード哲学百科事典「社会主義」第1節 ↗ (Japanese)
Related questions
- Why do Chiikawa and friends work?Money to live on, and money you want to spend on someone. Let's look at the life beyond the work.
- Is the weeding certification exam a fair system?Taking the same exam, and being able to prepare in the same way. Thinking about two kinds of “fairness.”
- Thinking about effort and luck from Chiikawa's houseCan the reason someone has a house be explained just by how hard they worked? Thinking it through from the sweepstakes scene.
- How is a gift different from shopping?The meaning of a sweet, which its price alone doesn't tell you. From a celebration of passing, I read the ties between people and things.